Aotearoa: Controversial bill to strip M膩ori people鈥檚 rights backfires

November 18, 2024
Issue 
Participants in the Hikoi
The H墨koi for the Treaty started in the far north at Cape Reinga on November 11 and is working its way towards the capital, Wellington. Photo: Sade Lomas

Aotearoa New Zealand鈥檚 parliament was brought to a halt on November 14 during the first reading of a controversial and divisive bill that aims to undermine the rights of M膩ori people.

The Treaty Principles Bill seeks to 鈥渞edefine鈥 the principles of Aotearoa鈥檚 founding document, the Treaty of Waitangi (te Tiriti o Waitangi). It has been tabled by the libertarian ACT Party which 鈥 along with NZ First 鈥 form part of the ruling coalition government, led by the National Party.

ACT leader David Seymour claims the current application of the Treaty is 鈥渃ontrary to the principle of equal rights鈥 and leads to policies divided by race.

However, M膩ori leaders and activists, historians, te reo M膩ori (M膩ori language) translators, politicians 鈥 including former prime ministers 鈥 and legal experts strongly oppose the bill.

The Waitangi Tribunal 鈥 a permanent commission of inquiry that oversees treaty matters 鈥 issued a highly critical . It said that the bill "does not reflect the texts or meaning of the Treaty/te Tiriti鈥, and the proposed principals are designed to 鈥渆nd the distinct status of M膩ori as the indigenous people of this country鈥.

It warned that the bill 鈥渨ill foster division and damage social cohesion, with significant prejudicial impacts on M膩ori鈥.

At the bill鈥檚 first reading debate since its introduction on November 7, MPs spoke in favour and against before it was put to a vote.

Green party co-leader Chloe Swarbrick said: 鈥淚f you wear the mask for a little while, it becomes your face 鈥 if you vote for this bill, this is who you are and this is how you will be remembered.鈥

Labour MP Willie Jackson called Seymour 鈥渁 liar鈥 and accused him of fuelling 鈥渉atred and misinformation鈥. He refused to apologise and was ejected from the chamber.

However, it was Te Pati M膩ori (M膩ori Party) MP Hana-Rawhiti Maipi-Clarke who gave the most impassioned protest by leading a haka (ceremonial dance) in the house.

After confirming in te reo M膩ori her party鈥檚 six votes against the bill, Maipi-Clarke stood and tore up a copy of it before starting the Ka Mate (which celebrates victory over adversity, or life over death). Fellow party members and other MPs, as well as some in the public gallery, joined in.

House speaker Gerry Brownlee suspended the sitting shortly afterwards. When MPs returned, they voted to suspend Maipi-Clarke for 24 hours for leading the protest and Brownlee 鈥渘amed鈥 her for misconduct.

After she was elected as the member for the Hauraki-Waikato electorate last year, Maipi-Clarke gained attention for performing a in her maiden speech to parliament. At 22 years old, she is Aotearoa鈥檚 second-youngest MP in history.

The bill eventually passed the first reading, backed by the coalition partners. Te Pati M膩ori, the Greens and Labour opposed it.

The bill will now go to a six-month committee for public submissions, after which recommendations will be made, before the bill goes back to parliament.

It is unlikely to proceed beyond that with ACT鈥檚 coalition partners stating from the outset they would not support it at its second reading.

National has never supported the proposal, but was bound by the terms of its coalition agreement with ACT to support the bill up to the select committee stage.

National Prime Minister Christopher Luxon stated publicly: 鈥淵ou do not go negate, with a single stroke of a pen, 184 years of debate and discussion, with a bill that I think is very simplistic.鈥

Luxon鈥檚 view highlights the performative nature of the bill鈥檚 introduction to parliament. While highly unlikely to succeed, ACT is pushing to galvanise a right-wing base. ACT only received 9% of the vote last year but has a disproportionate influence on politics because of its coalition with National.

Aotearoa鈥檚 citizens, and most of all M膩ori, are paying the price for National鈥檚 desperation to form a government.

Meanwhile, tens of thousands of people are currently travelling the length of te Ika-a-M膩ui (the North Island) in a 丑墨办辞颈 (peaceful march) to challenge the bill. It is one of the largest protest activations the country has ever seen.

The march, dubbed H墨koi m艒 Te Tiriti (H墨koi for the Treaty), started in the far north at Te Rerenga Wairua (Cape Reinga) on November 11 and is working its way towards Poneke (the capital, Wellington) over nine days and 1000 kilometres.

People from all walks of life have joined the 丑墨办辞颈, which is led by the M膩ori activist movement Toitu te Tiriti (Honour the Treaty).

The NZ Herald reported that 鈥渕any of the supporters on the 丑墨办辞颈 don鈥檛 consider themselves political activists. They are mums and dads, rangatahi (young people), professionals, P膩keh膩, and Tauiwi (other non-M膩ori ethnicities).鈥

The government tried to stifle the impact of the 丑墨办辞颈 by moving the bill鈥檚 first reading forward by two weeks. Initially, it was to be introduced to parliament on November 18, one day before the 丑墨办辞颈 ends.

In his speech during the first reading debate, Te Pati M膩ori co-leader Rawiri Waititi聽made a rallying call for M膩ori to rise up against the bill: 鈥淭e Tiriti was an arrangement to unify. This bill serves to divide. Te iwi M膩ori don鈥檛 expect this House to liberate us. We must be our own liberation.鈥

He ended by referencing the 丑墨办辞颈, which will conclude outside Parliament on November 19, audaciously telling Seymour: 鈥淪ee you next Tuesday鈥.

You need 91自拍论坛, and we need you!

91自拍论坛 is funded by contributions from readers and supporters. Help us reach our funding target.

Make a One-off Donation or choose from one of our Monthly Donation options.

Become a supporter to get the digital edition for $5 per month or the print edition for $10 per month. One-time payment options are available.

You can also call 1800 634 206 to make a donation or to become a supporter. Thank you.