A provisional ruling may come within weeks on South Africa鈥檚 compelling case of genocide against at the International Court of Justice (ICJ).
has implications for Australia and the United States, both of which are complicit in Israel鈥檚 genocide as all signatories to the are obliged not to participate in genocide and to actively prevent it.
Foreign minister Penny Wong began the government鈥檚 lobbying trip to the Middle East on January 15, saying Labor is 鈥済ravely concerned鈥 about the 鈥渨orsening humanitarian situation in Gaza鈥. Labor has refused to state its position on the ICJ case.
South Africa鈥檚 closely followed the provisions and provided evidence that Israel is committing crimes.
They include the mass killings of Palestinians 鈥 the first of five genocidal acts listed by the convention that become genocide when done with an intention to destroy an entire group of people in whole, or in part.
鈥淎s I stand before you today, 23,210 Palestinians have been killed by Israeli forces during the sustained attacks over the last three months,鈥 South African lawyer Adila Hassim .
Hassim cited United Nations (UN) Secretary-General saying on December 6 that 鈥渘owhere is safe in Gaza鈥 and that Israel has bombed civilians 鈥渆ven while they attempted to flee along Israeli declared 鈥榮afe routes鈥欌.
According to the , Israel has killed an 鈥渦nparalleled and unprecedented鈥 number of civilians, she said.
Another genocidal act is to inflict conditions calculated to bring about the physical destruction of the group, in whole or in part. Israel has done this in many ways, Hassim said.
These include the forced displacement of 85% of Gaza鈥檚 population and denying food, water and electricity to the population, leading to mass hunger, dehydration and starvation.
She cited Israel鈥檚 of access to a 鈥減lanned mission by UN agencies to deliver urgent medical supplies and vital fuel to a hospital and medical supply centre鈥.
鈥淭his marked the fifth denial of a mission to the centre since 26 December, leaving five hospitals in northern Gaza without access to life-saving medical supplies and equipment.鈥
Imposing measures designed to prevent births within a targeted group is another genocidal act.
Hassim also highlighted the by Reem Alsalem, UN Special Rapporteur on violence against women and girls.
鈥淭he reproductive violence inflicted by Israel on Palestinian women, newborn babies, infants, and children could be qualified as 鈥 acts of genocide under Article 2 of the [Genocide Convention]鈥 Alsalem said.
Key to the crime of genocide is the intention to destroy an entire group of people, in whole or in part.
US/Israeli genocide expert聽 that this 鈥渟pecial intent鈥 is often hard to prove, but that in Israel鈥檚 case, the 鈥渟pecial intent is on full display鈥.
The South African case devotes almost 10 pages to genocidal comments from leading Israeli politicians and officials, including Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu.
Tembeka Ngcukaitobi, who represented South Africa at the ICJ, said Israel鈥檚 genocidal intent is both 鈥渆vident from the way in which Israel鈥檚 military attack is being conducted鈥 and also from the 鈥渟peech[es] by leaders and military officials鈥.
鈥淚srael鈥檚 special genocidal intent is rooted in the belief that in fact the 鈥榚nemy鈥 is not just the military wing of Hamas, or indeed Hamas generally, but is embedded in the fabric of Palestinian life in Gaza,鈥 he said.
Israel told the ICJ on January 12 that it has a right to defend itself. It also detailed its alleged plan to mitigate civilian hardship, arguing that, together, these are incompatible with genocidal intention.
International legal expert Alonso Gurmendi told journalist Owen Jones on that 鈥渁 lot of people say [Israel鈥檚 defence] was terrible. It wasn鈥檛.鈥
He cautioned Palestine supporters, not to think 鈥渢his is going to be a walk in the park鈥, while pointing out that Israel鈥檚 defence 鈥渉as its flaws and has its points where you can counter-argue successfully鈥.
Gurmendi argued that international law was born out of 鈥渃olonialist principles鈥, and was not set up to 鈥渆nable liberation鈥. 鈥淕enocide is common,鈥 he said, whereas 鈥渇indings of genocide are not鈥.
Labor is feeling pressure from the huge pro-Palestine solidarity movement across the country, sustained over 14 weeks. The persuasive power of the South African ICJ case only adds to it.
After refusing to call for a ceasefire for two full months, Australia voted for a 鈥渉umanitarian ceasefire鈥 at the UN General Assembly on December 13.
Despite Israel鈥檚 to encourage allies to make supportive statements, Labor has on South Africa鈥檚 ICJ case.
Wong鈥檚 trip has been framed by Labor as a chance to 鈥渃aution鈥 Israel over 鈥渉umanitarian concerns鈥. She announced $21 million in emergency funding for Gaza, a small amount and more than half of which is for 鈥渞efugee programs in Lebanon and Jordan鈥.
This mounting pressure is not yet powerful enough to force a change of policy.
This was revealed by Australia鈥檚 with New Zealand and Canada on December 13 which, despite appearances, only called for 鈥渟teps towards鈥 a ceasefire, not a permanent ceasefire. The statement also made demands on Hamas, not Israel.
Now, Labor is talking about a 鈥渟ustainable ceasefire鈥 鈥 leaving itself a lot of wriggle room.
While Labor declined a US request in December to send a warship to the Red Sea, it on Yemen, arguing it is in the country鈥檚 鈥渘ational interest鈥. Labor also claims to not want the conflict to spread.
Houthi rebels in war-ravaged Yemen are targeting Israeli vessels over the Gaza genocide, and have managed to get most shipping lines to reroute.
About聽12% of global trade passes through the Red Sea and about 30% of the world鈥檚 container shipping. Access to the Red Sea requires access through the Bab al Mandab 鈥 a narrow strait between Djibouti to the west and Yemen to the east.
The Biden administration has just declared the Houthi to be a 鈥渟pecially designated global terrorist group鈥. The AUKUS arrangement means that Australia will likely follow suit.