Labor鈥檚 budget ignores the needs of millions

May 10, 2023
Issue 
This budget betrays renters, job seekers and people doing it tough. Image: 91自拍论坛

Labor鈥檚 budget provided few surprises on May 9. Many of the measures had been judiciously leaked,聽hoping to dampen any outrage from the corporate sector, in particular.

Most were nonplussed at the breaking news, that morning, that the budget would be in the black 鈥 by $4.2 billion 鈥 for the first time in 15 years. For Labor, it鈥檚 more important to be seen as 鈥済ood economic managers鈥 than to lift people out of poverty.

The already rich will receive $25 a day, compared to those on the lowest incomes will receive $2.85.

The Australian Council of Social Service鈥檚 (ACOSS) to Prime Minister Anthony Albanese to lift JobSeeker and other payments to address 鈥渟tructural injustice鈥 and 鈥渋ncreased deprivation鈥 signed by an impressive list of MPs (including Labor, Greens ans聽independents),聽economists, academics, philanthropists, businesses, unions and First Nations' leaders, was ignored.

Job seekers and those on Youth Allowance will receive a miserable $20 more a week, nothing near the 90% increase ACOSS had been urging in聽the current聽cost-of-living crisis. The increase is also lower than the rise allocated by Scott Morrison鈥檚 government in聽.

There were also some sweeteners for those struggling on low incomes: a 15% rise to rent assistance; $500 in energy bill relief for concession card holders; $3.5 billion over five years to encourage doctors to bulk bill and 320 medicines on the Pharmaceutical Benefits Scheme halved in price.

But, as ACOSS CEO Cassandra Goldie said, the measures 鈥渨ill still leave more than one million people in poverty, unable to afford three meals a day and a roof over their head鈥. Australia is one of the richest countries in the world, she said, yet unemployment benefits are among the lowest in the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development.

Wringing his hands, Treasurer Jim Chalmers made a point of repeating that Labor鈥檚 cost-of-living relief 鈥渄oesn鈥檛 add to inflation鈥. Yet these sweetener sums 鈥 totalling about $14.6 billion 鈥 are paltry when stacked up against the Stage 3 tax cuts 鈥 a $254 billion cut to聽the federal budget over the next 10 years.

The tax cuts, introduced by the Coalition, were supported by Labor then, and continue to be now. The already rich will receive $25 a day, compared to those on the lowest incomes will receive $2.85.

It shows where Labor鈥檚 class sympathies lie.

Even the joined the call to scrap tax cuts for a raise in JobSeeker payments.

Labor claims to be the party for workers, because of its commitment to social welfare and the environment. But example after example in this budget show Labor is tinkering around the edges while window-dressing big-ticket items 鈥 such as the $11.3 billion for aged-care workers鈥 wages 鈥 to try and sell the idea it is addressing the working people鈥檚 needs.

On the urgently needed transition away from fossil fuels and carbon emission reductions, the budget allocations are minuscule 鈥 in the millions only.

However, $2 billion has been allocated to driving the development of clean hydrogen. Hydrogen is a marginal alternative energy and it can be powered by 鈥渂rown鈥 or 鈥済reen鈥 energy: there are big profits to be made by private corporations if Labor pours in subsidies.

Apart from the anti-China push and militarisation of the Asia-Pacific, Labor鈥檚 $368 billion commitment to the AUKUS nuclear-powered submarines is another looming environmental disaster: no First Nations community wants nuclear waste dumped on Country, and a nuclear war with China will certainly be one to end all environments.

By refusing to budge on the Stage 3 tax cuts, Labor is sending a message to capital (and us) that it can be relied on to protect their interests.

A small surplus, and the barely discussed $17.8 billion savings across government agencies, tells big the corporate sector it has their interests at heart if there is another global financial crisis: there鈥檚 plenty of money in the kitty if corporate Australia needs to be bailed out.

How else can Labor鈥檚 refusal to spend just $24 billion to lift JobSeeker to a living wage be understood?

This budget betrays renters, job seekers and people doing it tough. It leaves millions stuck in poverty while billionaires get tax cuts. The challenge is to build a united mass movement that can force Labor to act for聽the millions left behind by this budget.

[Sue Bull is a member of the National Executive.]

You need 91自拍论坛, and we need you!

91自拍论坛 is funded by contributions from readers and supporters. Help us reach our funding target.

Make a One-off Donation or choose from one of our Monthly Donation options.

Become a supporter to get the digital edition for $5 per month or the print edition for $10 per month. One-time payment options are available.

You can also call 1800 634 206 to make a donation or to become a supporter. Thank you.