Venezuela: Court rejects appeal by left-wing opposition to publish presidential election results

November 7, 2024
Issue 
Two faces
Mar铆a Alejandra D铆az (left) and Nicolas Maduro. Photo: @_TribunaPopular/X and Wikipedia

More than two months after the passing of a 30-day legal deadline, Venezuela鈥檚 National Electoral Council (CNE) has still not published the full results of the July 28 presidential election.

Despite this, the Constitutional Chamber of the Supreme Court of Justice (TSJ) rejected an appeal on November 4 calling on it to request the CNE comply with Article 155 of the Organic Law of Electoral Processes and the TSJ鈥檚 own August 22 ruling that the electoral body 鈥減ublish definitive results for the electoral process鈥.

Instead, the TSJ fined Mar铆a Alejandra D铆az, the lawyer who lodged the appeal on behalf of various left-wing organisations, and suspended her from professional duties.

According to the CNE, incumbent president Nicol谩s Maduro won the presidential election with more than 51% of the votes. However, the right-wing opposition has disputed the result, claiming alleged voting centre tally sheets in its possession indicate victory for its candidate, Edmundo Gonz谩lez.

Given conflicting claims, publication of the results is required to verify who won.

CNE head Elvis Amoroso promised to do just that on election night, saying this would happen 鈥渋n the next few hours, as has traditionally occurred鈥 and 鈥渋n accordance with the law鈥.

But more than three months on, the CNE鈥檚 failure to do so led to the Popular Democratic Front (FDP) lodging its appeal.

The FDP includes left-wing parties and organisations such as Redes, the Popular Historic Bloc, the Communist Party of Venezuela, The Other Campaign, Anti-imperialist Voices, Alternative Popular Movement, In Common and the National Front of Working Class Struggle.

Former presidential candidate , who also co-signed the appeal, explained in a November 3 Televen interview that its purpose was to request that the TSJ 鈥渄emand the CNE publish the results so that not only I as a candidate, but the people can know exactly what occurred鈥.

He added that 鈥減erhaps no one should be more interested in this happening than the government itself, as it would generate clarity about the results, [and] clarity about its own legitimacy based on those results.

鈥淏ut so far that has not happened. All this does is generate more and more doubts.鈥

The TSJ instead ruled that by lodging the appeal, D铆az was 鈥渜uestioning and disrespecting the power vested鈥 in the TSJ and 鈥渟eeking to generate anxiety and commotion in the population鈥.

As a result, a disciplinary procedure has been opened up against the former legal adviser to the ruling United Socialist Party of Venezuela, with the threat of further punishment hanging over her head.

D铆az denounced the court鈥檚 decision as 鈥渘ot only an abuse of power, but an overreach and a clear warning to those wanting to exercise their political rights鈥

鈥淲ho will now want to defend political and social causes such as this, if they face such punishment?鈥

Numerous organisations and individuals have come out in defence of D铆az, including left-wing human rights organisation Surgentes.

In their statement, Surgentes notes that if anyone has been 鈥渞esponsible for generating anxiety and commotion鈥 it has been the CNE 鈥渂y not publishing the full electoral results and failing to fulfil its legal obligations of transparency and auditability鈥.

It added the state as a whole was also culpable, for continuing to 鈥渋nsist that the population accept a government that cannot demonstrate that it was elected by a majority [of voters]鈥.

The decision by the TSJ to reject the appeal is just one of the latest actions taken by the Venezuelan state to repress those who have dared to question Maduro鈥檚 victory.

For example, the National Assembly is currently discussing proposed reforms to the electoral system that, according to interior minister Diosdado Cabello, would 鈥渨ho does not recognise the results announced by the [CNE]鈥 from being able to participate in elections.

Meanwhile, about 2000 people remain in jail after being arrested during the wave of post-election protests demanding that the people鈥檚 vote be respected.

The majority of those in jail, which includes 69 adolescents, hail from poor working-class areas that traditionally voted for Maduro. Most are facing charges of 鈥渢errorism鈥 and 鈥渋nciting hate鈥.

According to Marquez, this is 鈥渢he largest number of political prisoners in the entire history of Venezuela. Even if we go back to the time of [military dictator Marco] P茅rez Jim茅nez, there were not as many prisoners鈥

鈥淭his is how the government intends to lead our country, through terror [and] by force.鈥

Marquez explained: 鈥淭hose who have been imprisoned have had all their rights violated, they are not allowed visits, they are not allowed to have a private lawyer, they are not allowed the right to a defence, access to the judge is by telephone.

鈥淚magine a hearing 鈥 being held by telephone, where the accused is not even allowed an appearance before the judge.

鈥淣ot only are the rights established in the Constitution being violated, but everything established in the Organic Code of Criminal Procedure is being violated. These people are wrongly imprisoned and should be released as soon as possible.鈥

You need 91自拍论坛, and we need you!

91自拍论坛 is funded by contributions from readers and supporters. Help us reach our funding target.

Make a One-off Donation or choose from one of our Monthly Donation options.

Become a supporter to get the digital edition for $5 per month or the print edition for $10 per month. One-time payment options are available.

You can also call 1800 634 206 to make a donation or to become a supporter. Thank you.